- Indicators
- 3
- Leaders
- 10placeholder ratings
- Like it
- 8capabilities
- Developments
- 32
What Research Commercialisation & Knowledge Transfer is, and how it is measured
The capacity to turn research into enterprise: transfer offices, licensing, spinout formation and the standing bridges between the research base and the firms that carry its results to market.
Indicators
- University spinouts formed
- Licensing income of research institutions
- Industry funding of academic research
The nations that lead in Research Commercialisation & Knowledge Transfer
These ratings stand in until the capability is rated.
| # | Nation | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Germany | AAA |
| 2 | United Kingdom | AA |
| 3 | United States | AA |
| 4 | Canada | A |
| 5 | Singapore | A |
| 6 | Norway | A |
| 7 | Netherlands | BBB |
| 8 | France | BBB |
| 9 | Switzerland | BB |
| 10 | South Korea | BB |
The capabilities most like Research Commercialisation & Knowledge Transfer
- Roads & Bridges0.09
Likeness, from 0 to 1, as the Atlas measures it.
How Research Commercialisation & Knowledge Transfer came to be
- Geopolitical
- Governance
- Security
- Technology
- Economy
- Environment
- Society
Historical Developments
Oldest first80,000 BCE
Humans began transferring knowledge with the "Great Leap Forward" in behavioural modernity
Knowledge transfer between humans is thought to date to the emergence of behavioural modernity roughly 80,000 years ago, with the origin of speech possibly as early as 100,000 BCE. Abstract thinking, symbolic behaviour, music, dance and blade technology are treated as indicators of this shift, which made the passing of practical skills between people possible.
roughly 1500 BCE · roughly 3,500 years ago
Ironworking technology spread outward from Anatolia across the ancient world
Smelting techniques developed under the Hittites diffused through trade and conquest into Mesopotamia, Egypt and eventually Europe and South Asia, one of the earliest documented technology transfers to reshape agriculture and warfare across multiple civilisations.
5th century · roughly 1,575 years ago
Nalanda drew students from across Asia to transmit Buddhist and scientific learning
The monastic university in northern India attracted scholars from China, Korea and Southeast Asia, who studied medicine, mathematics and philosophy before carrying that learning back to their home countries over several centuries.
12th century · roughly 875 years ago
The Toledo School of Translators rendered Arabic scientific and philosophical works into Latin
Scholars in Toledo translated Islamic advances in mathematics, medicine and astronomy, alongside Greek texts preserved and extended in the Arabic-speaking world, becoming a principal channel through which this knowledge entered medieval Europe.
13th century · roughly 775 years ago
The Mongol Empire's unification of Eurasian trade routes accelerated the transfer of Chinese and Islamic technology across the continent
Papermaking, printing and gunpowder moved west while astronomical and mathematical knowledge moved east under the relative security of the Pax Mongolica, one of history's largest state-enabled flows of technology between civilisations.
1870s–1890s · roughly 145 years ago
Meiji Japan employed thousands of foreign engineers and teachers under fixed-term contracts
The oyatoi gaikokujin programme brought Western specialists to build railways and factories and to train Japanese successors, a deliberate state effort to import technical knowledge directly into domestic institutions rather than relying solely on missions sent abroad.
1943 · 83 years ago
Ryan and Gross recognised the diffusion of innovation as an essential social process
Their study identified interpersonal contact as pivotal in the spread of innovations among individuals. This marked an early landmark in the scientific study of knowledge transfer, which had begun in the first half of the twentieth century with a focus on innovation adoption.
1945 · 81 years ago
Post-war academia turned to knowledge transfer research in the information age
The period after the Second World War was characterised as the information age, raising motivation to promote wider use of knowledge. Three demands drove academic research: rapid technological change for economic growth, transfer of technology from defence and space research, and adoption of innovations in health, education and human services. Researchers tested strategies including print materials, films, consultation, technical assistance, networks and training conferences.
1948 · 78 years ago
The Marshall Plan funded productivity missions to American factories
Thousands of European managers, engineers and trade unionists travelled to the United States to study mass-production and management techniques, transferring organisational know-how across the Atlantic alongside the plan's financial aid to rebuild Western Europe.
1953 · 73 years ago
Sony licensed transistor technology from Western Electric
A modest royalty payment gave the struggling Japanese firm rights to a technology it had not invented, which it then miniaturised into the transistor radio, launching a business that helped turn Japan into a major electronics exporter.
1966 · 60 years ago
The International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center institutionalised the transfer of Green Revolution crop varieties
High-yield, disease-resistant wheat developed in Mexico was carried to Pakistan and India through the new research centre and its national partners, part of a programme credited with averting famine across South Asia within a decade.
- Norman Borlaug had trained a generation of South Asian agronomists directly
1973 · 53 years ago
Nippon Steel transferred steelmaking technology that built POSCO
Japanese technical assistance, financed partly through post-colonial reparations, gave South Korea's new state steelmaker the process technology to build its first blast furnace, turning the country from a steel importer into a major regional producer within a decade.
1990s · 36 years ago
Management scholarship took up the subject under the title of knowledge management
From the 1990s knowledge transfer was framed within knowledge management and the knowledge-based theory of the firm. This reframing treated knowledge as a firm's stock and made intra-firm transfer a central business concern.
1990s · 36 years ago
Szulanski identified internal stickiness as an impediment to transferring best practice within firms
His doctoral dissertation argued that knowledge transfer within a firm is inhibited by factors other than lack of incentive, depending on the nature of the knowledge, its source, its recipient and the organisational context. The 'stickiness' metaphor, drawn from circulating viscous fluid in an oil refinery, became a widely cited concept in the field.
1991 · 35 years ago
Backer proposed six crucial points for knowledge utilisation
Backer set out interpersonal contact, planning and conceptual foresight, outside consultation, user-oriented transformation of information, individual and organisational championship, and potential user involvement. The framework codified conditions under which innovations are successfully adopted in new settings.
2000 · 26 years ago
Argote and Ingram defined knowledge transfer as one unit being affected by the experience of another
Their definition framed transfer as observable through changes in the knowledge or performance of recipient units. They also noted that although the benefits are well known, effectiveness varies considerably and transfer of organisational best practice is often difficult.
Recent Developments
Most recent firstEarly 2026 · 6 months ago
China kept attracting returning diaspora scientists as research security tightened abroad
Universities and state laboratories continued recruiting researchers of Chinese origin returning from the United States and Europe, a flow that officials and analysts linked to tighter foreign-talent screening and funding scrutiny in Western research systems.
Early 2026 · 6 months ago
The WHO's mRNA technology transfer hub moved several partner countries toward local vaccine production
The Cape Town-based hub, which reverse-engineered an mRNA vaccine platform and licensed it onward without permission from the original developers, reported partner manufacturers in Africa, Asia and Latin America advancing candidate vaccines through early clinical testing.
- Afrigen Biologics continued training scientists from partner countries
November 2025 · last year
COP30 in Belém put climate technology transfer back on the negotiating table
Talks in the Brazilian Amazon revisited how developing countries could gain faster access to renewable energy and adaptation technology, building on the finance goal agreed at the previous year's summit and longstanding complaints that transfer commitments were rarely met.
2025 · last year
Japan continued transferring high-speed rail technology to India
Work on the Mumbai-Ahmedabad corridor kept training Indian engineers and technicians on Shinkansen signalling, track and rolling stock systems under a financing and technology package agreed nearly a decade before the current construction phase.
2025 · last year
Saudi Arabia pushed defence technology transfer conditions through its localisation programme
The General Authority for Military Industries continued requiring foreign arms suppliers to transfer manufacturing and maintenance know-how to Saudi partners as a condition of contracts, part of a target to localise around half of military spending.
2025 · last year
Tata Electronics advanced its Dholera semiconductor plant on licensed fabrication technology
Construction of India's first large commercial chip fabrication plant progressed using process technology licensed from Taiwan's Powerchip Semiconductor Manufacturing Corporation, an early example of foreign know-how underpinning India's push into advanced chipmaking.
- Powerchip provided training and process design support
2025 · last year
China and the United States kept forced technology transfer as a sticking point in trade talks
Washington continued to press complaints that market access to China was conditioned on sharing proprietary technology with local partners, an issue that resurfaced repeatedly in tariff negotiations without a durable resolution.
2024 · 2 years ago
Rwanda and Senegal expanded containerised mRNA manufacturing capacity transferred from BioNTech
Modular production units installed in Kigali and planned for Dakar continued to be staffed and commissioned, part of a strategy to place vaccine manufacturing technology directly on the continent rather than relying on imported doses during future outbreaks.
- Local technicians took over a growing share of facility operation
2024 · 2 years ago
Aspen Pharmacare struggled to convert licensed vaccine technology into sustained production
The South African manufacturer, which had gained rights to produce a licensed COVID-19 vaccine, continued to face insufficient international orders to run its facility at scale, a widely cited example of the gap between transferring technology and building a durable market for it.
2024 · 2 years ago
Indonesia continued requiring smelting technology transfer from foreign nickel investors
Rules barring the export of unprocessed nickel ore kept pushing mostly Chinese investors to build smelters and battery-material plants on Indonesian soil, with technology transfer and local employment conditions attached to processing licences.
2021 · 5 years ago
Sailer and colleagues reduced knowledge transfer to linear, divergent and convergent subtypes
Based on the number of sources and recipients, they classified all types of knowledge transfer into three subtypes. The typology offered a structural way to compare transfer situations.
2009 · 17 years ago
MIT survey ranked the channels of academic knowledge transfer by importance
A survey of MIT professors identified and ordered the channels through which academic knowledge reaches other parties. It gave empirical weight to the relative importance of different transfer routes from universities.
2009 · 17 years ago
Nonaka set out four patterns of knowledge conversion between tacit and explicit knowledge
The distinction between explicit and tacit knowledge was used to describe four basic patterns for translating knowledge, interacting in a spiral manner. This provided a widely used mechanism-level account of how knowledge moves between people and organisations.
2006 · 20 years ago
Turner identified five factors shaping knowledge transfer in forest landscape ecology
The factors were research capacity generation, potential for application, users of the knowledge, infrastructure capacity, and the transfer process itself. This extended knowledge transfer analysis into environmental and landscape science.
2003 · 23 years ago
United Kingdom commissioned the Lambert Review of business-university collaboration
The review examined knowledge transfer between the public and private domains in the UK. It made collaboration between businesses and universities a matter of explicit national policy attention.
2001 · 25 years ago
The World Trade Organization adopted the Doha Declaration on TRIPS and Public Health
Members affirmed the right of developing countries to issue compulsory licences overriding patent protection to access essential medicines, a mechanism used soon afterwards to widen production of HIV and AIDS antiretroviral drugs beyond the original patent holders.
- South Africa and Brazil had pressed hardest for the declaration
A timeline taken from the English Wikipedia article “Knowledge transfer” (CC BY-SA 4.0), the only source the Atlas consulted for it.